[Punisher]

For this test to be accurate, all stats would have to be equal accross the board. The victim would have to have the same vital stats each attack, as would the attacker. Since the two weapons in question are similar in requirements, they should be similar in damage capable. As stated before, most people train for ranged, as have I just because the ranged weapons were better at the time. I am getting very frequent big hits with the 450. I have to say, melee is lots of fun if you cant get into the 450, the electric axe has some huge hits.

Whichever you train for if you stats are up there, you are gonna get some big hits and it all goes back to your training